Find a Caterer in Cayuga Heights

These hand pies are the main reason I go to the farmers market. As I've posted before, the mushroom and Oaxacan cheese pies are a gastronomic delight. Today I have to recommend the feta and chard pies! They are so tangy and the filling has such a wonderful silky texture. You gotta try it. Im not sure how its possible, but I think their crust is even more buttery, flakey and perfect every time I eat there. Most all of their ingredients are local, and produced in environmentally friendly/ethical ways. You can really taste the quality. If you go to the farmers market and don't try one of their many delicious pie, you are missing out big time! The people who make the pies are lovely people, so make sure to say hi if there isn't a huge line.

Amazing location for a celebration. It was a rustic barn before rustic barns were cool. Nicole is good people and will take great care of you!

Serendipity impressed me from our first conversation and it only got better from there. During the planning process it was clear they were experienced and detail oriented. They provided a highly itemized spreadsheet with every item needed for our event and who was responsible for providing them. When they showed up the day of the event it was like an army was invading - in a good way. I simply showed them the areas for the back of house, reception bar and dinner and the team immediately set to work. It was clear they had done this many times before. They teamwork was impressive and inspiring. Even our CEO relaxed because he could see we were in good hands.Being highly organized and coordinated is great, but the real payoff came when dinner was served. The food was delicious. This was an annual event and some of the guests who had attended previous years commented that it was the best dinner yet. I look forward to the next opportunity to work with Serendipity.

In a nutshell...."THE BEST" !!!!! Ithacas' new "in"place is worthy of all the acc olades that it will receive. Great food, affordable prices and owners that care. See you there !!!

Amazing. Beautiful, newly-renovated interior space with very professional staff and amazing food. Making reservations is a quick and easy phonecall. Not sure you could go wrong with anything on the menu. Amy at the bar is amazing. A little on the pricey side but totally worth it for a fine dining experience. One of the best restaurants on the Commons!

My one year old daughter had a blast. The space is very small but great for toddlers.

I always use them for getting food from places that won't deliver. Sometimes i need REAL ribs and not skinny little things you get from chinese delivery. Even though it costs a little extra its worth it to me. I saw someone mention drivers expect tips like its a bad thing. The drivers aren't paid hourly and they survive on the tips. Its important to them so don't feel they are trying to rip you off. You are helping them more than you realize. Enjoy the ribs!

Ithaca Bakery is catering my wedding reception in June and, although the date has yet to arrive, they have just been amazingly helpful through the planning process. In addition to the figuring out the catering, their staff has really gone out of their way to answer any questions I may have about any part of the wedding and lend suggestions about other vendors, locations, and simple tips to pull off a great wedding. Very helpful, fun to work with and, oh yeah, the food is great!

I love the staff here all friendly and provide amazing service to the Tompkins county area

Simply the best wine shop I have ever been to. The selection is careful—not the largest in town by any measure, but instead well-curated and full of oddities nobody else has. The staff is jaw-droppingly knowledgeable—everyone there seems to know every single bottle in the store, and can make recommendations with ease. All of them are friendly, helpful, and just as capable of helping a confused wine newbie as a serious oenophile.

rooms are beautiful and employees are so nice